Getting Lost with Mapping Sites

An article in yesterday’s New York Times (free registration required) about getting lost using the directions in online mapping services. Key graf: “Roughly 1 in 50 computer-generated directions is a dud, according to Doug Richardson, the executive director for the Association of American Geographers. He blames inaccurate road information for most of the failures.” Via All Points Blog.

See previous entries: Google Maps’s MapPoint Moment; Where Do You Want to Go Today?; Good Maps, Bad Maps.

Posted on Wednesday, June 29, 2005 at 10:40 AM
Categories: Online Maps

Comments

People don’t realise the vast amount of data that needs to be compiled to run these systems, no one provider can do it all, in fact all of them together with millions of man and machine hours and billion plus estimated collective dollars; still only have good coverage for those areas that have the most commercial interest and major inter-regional roads. If you want to see where the breakdown is highest just select remote forested areas such as oregon, or nevada, or wyoming, etc. The data will be 20 years out of date, routing will be marginal, errors high. Just a few observations along that line. What is silly is that people expect that great data is already build and freely available. The market will mature as the in car navigation market takes off and increased profitability and competiveness will drive buying and building better and more complete datasets as well as newer software functions to interact with that information.
waban*

This entry is more than 30 days old and is closed to new comments.

Comments on all entries are available via RSS.